American Cheese Slices vs Sharp Cheddar Cheese Slices?

Direct Answer: Both American cheese and sharp cheddar slices have their merits and are suitable for different dishes. American cheese melts smoothly and is often used in sandwiches and burgers for its creamy texture and mild taste. On the other hand, Sharp cheddar offers a more robust flavor and firmer texture, perfect for gourmet dishes and cheese platters.

American cheese slices and sharp cheddar cheese slices are two popular choices in the dairy aisle. However, they have unique characteristics, making them suited for different dishes. American cheese slices, known for their creamy consistency and mild, slightly salty flavor, are a staple in comfort foods across the United States. With a history that dates back to the 12th century in the English village of Cheddar, these slices are far from mild. They pack a robust, tangy flavor that only intensifies with age. Unlike their American counterpart, sharp cheddar slices are less processed and have a firmer, crumblier texture that adds a certain gourmet touch to various dishes.

What Is American Cheese?

What Is American Cheese
American Cheese

American cheese is a type of processed cheese that originated in the United States. It’s made from a blend of cheeses, typically Colby and cheddar, and other ingredients like milk, milk fats and solids, and emulsifiers. These emulsifiers help the cheese melt smoothly without separating, a characteristic quality of American cheese. Originally, it was made to be a more economical and longer-lasting alternative to traditional cheeses. It was created to be easily and consistently produced, with a flavor generally milder and less complex than traditional, aged cheeses.

It comes in various forms, including slices, blocks, and spreads. It’s often used in cheeseburgers, grilled cheese sandwiches, and other comfort foods due to its creamy texture and exceptional melting qualities. Despite its name, American cheese is enjoyed in many parts of the world.

What Is Sharp Cheddar Cheese?

What Is Sharp Cheddar Cheese
Sharp Cheddar Cheese

>Sharp cheddar cheese is a type of cheddar cheese that has been aged longer than its mild counterparts. The “sharp” in sharp cheddar refers to its intense, deeply nutty, and slightly tangy flavor, which becomes more pronounced with age. Typically, sharp cheddar is aged 6 to 9 months, but some versions are even longer, sometimes for several years. The texture of sharp cheddar can also become more crumbly and less creamy as it ages. It’s commonly used in dishes like macaroni and cheese, sandwiches, and cheese platters, adding a robust flavor profile.

Is Cheddar More Popular Than American Cheese?

Is Cheddar More Popular Than American Cheese
American Cheese vs Cheddar Cheese

The popularity of cheddar versus American cheese can largely depend on regional preferences and the specific dish. Globally, cheddar cheese is often more popular due to its traditional manufacturing process, versatility, and robust flavor profile. It’s widely used in various cuisines, from British to Mexican, and can be enjoyed in many ways: on a cheeseboard, in sandwiches, melted over nachos, and more.

However, American cheese tends to be more popular in the United States, particularly in comfort foods like cheeseburgers and grilled cheese sandwiches. Its smooth melting properties and creamy, mild flavor make it a staple in many American kitchens.

American Cheese Slices vs Sharp Cheddar Cheese Slices


American cheese has its roots in the early 20th century and is a product of the industrial revolution. On the other hand, cheddar has a rich history dating back to the 12th century in the English village of Cheddar.


American cheese has a smooth and creamy texture that melts evenly, making it perfect for grilled cheese sandwiches and burgers. On the other hand, Sharp cheddar cheese has a crumbly texture and does not melt as smoothly but offers a delightful bite when used in dishes.


American cheese has a mild, slightly salty flavor. Sharp cheddar is known for its intense, rich, and slightly nutty taste.


American cheese is processed and made with milk, cream, and various emulsifiers. Sharp cheddar cheese is traditionally made by cheddaring – heating, cutting, stacking, and pressing the curds.


American cheese is widely used in comfort foods like burgers, macaroni, and cheese. Sharp cheddar is versatile and is used in various gourmet dishes, cheese platters, soups, and sauces.


Monterey Jack or Colby cheese can be used as substitutes for American cheese. For sharp cheddar, one can use Swiss cheese or Gouda.

Nutritional Info:

American cheese and sharp cheddar cheese vary in nutritional content. Generally, cheddar cheese is higher in fat, calories, protein, and calcium than American cheese.


Price varies by brand and quality, but sharp cheddar cheese is generally more expensive due to its traditional manufacturing process.

Melting Property:

American cheese is known for its excellent melting property, providing a smooth, creamy texture. Sharp cheddar doesn’t melt as evenly but provides a stringy, gooey melt.

How To Make American Cheese Slices At Home?

>Making homemade American cheese slices is an interesting project and allows you to control the ingredients. Here is a step-by-step guide to help you through the process:


  • 1 1/2 cups of shredded Colby-Jack cheese
  • 1/2 cup of whole milk
  • 1 tablespoon of unflavored gelatin
  • 1 tablespoon of water
  • 1/2 teaspoon of salt


Step 1: Preparation: Line a loaf pan with plastic wrap, leaving extra on the sides for easy cheese removal later.

Step 2: Mix Gelatin and Water: In a small bowl, sprinkle the gelatin over the water and allow it to bloom for a few minutes.

Step 3: Heat the Milk: Bring the milk to a simmer over medium heat in a saucepan.

Step 4: Combine Ingredients: Add the bloomed gelatin and salt once the milk is heated. Stir until the gelatin is fully dissolved.

Step 5: Add the Cheese: Remove the mixture from the heat, add the shredded cheese, and stir until the cheese is completely melted and incorporated.

Step 6: Pour and Chill: Pour the mixture into the prepared loaf pan, then smooth the top with a spatula. Refrigerate for at least 2 hours or until the cheese is firm and sliceable.

Step 7: Slice and Enjoy: Once firm, remove the cheese from the pan using the plastic wrap. Peel off the plastic, then slice the cheese to your desired thickness. Use these slices as you would with any store-bought American cheese slices.

Remember, homemade American cheese will not have quite the same properties as the processed store-bought variety, but it will still be delicious and great for melting.

How To Make Sharp Cheddar Cheese At Home?[/su_heading]

Making sharp cheddar cheese at home is more complex than making American cheese, as it involves specific cheese-making ingredients and equipment and requires aging to develop the sharp flavor. Here’s a basic guide to the process:


  • 2 gallons of whole cow’s milk (not ultra-pasteurized)
  • 1/8 tsp Mesophilic starter culture (MA4002/MA4004)
  • 1/2 tsp liquid calcium chloride (diluted in 1/4 cup non-chlorinated water)
  • 1/2 tsp liquid rennet (diluted in 1/4 cup non-chlorinated water)
  • Cheese salt (to taste, typically about 1 tbsp)
  • Cheese wax (for aging)


  • Large stainless-steel pot (4-gallon capacity)
  • Cheese thermometer
  • Long knife (for cutting curds)
  • Cheese mold and follower
  • Cheese press
  • Cheese mat


Step 1: Sanitize Equipment: Ensure that all equipment is thoroughly sanitized before starting.

Step 2: Warm Milk: Pour the milk into your pot and heat slowly to 85°F (29°C).

Step 3: Add Ingredients: Add the starter culture and stir well. Let the milk sit for 45 minutes. Then add the calcium chloride solution, followed by the rennet solution, stirring well after each addition.

Step 4: Cut Curds: After about 45 minutes, the milk should have been set. Cut the curd into 1/4-inch cubes and let it rest for 5 minutes.

Step 5: Heat Curds: Slowly heat the curds to 102°F (39°C), stirring gently. This should take 30-45 minutes.

Step 6: Stir Curds: Continue stirring the curds for another 30 minutes.

Step 7: Drain Curds: Pour off the whey down to the level of the curds, then transfer the curds to a cheese mold positioned over a draining area.

Step 8: Press Cheese: Press the cheese at 20 lbs of pressure for 45 minutes. Then remove the cheese from the mold, flip it, and press at 40 lbs for 3 hours. Finally, flip again and press at 50 lbs for 24 hours.

Step 9: Salt Cheese: Remove the cheese from the press and place it in a brine solution (roughly 1 lb salt to 1 gallon water) for 12 hours.

Step 10: Dry Cheese: Pat the cheese dry and let it air-dry for 2-3 days at room temperature until it’s dry to the touch.

Step 11: Wax and Age Cheese: Wax the cheese in a cheese cave at 50-55°F (10-13°C) for at least 60 days for a mild cheddar, but ideally 6-24 months for a sharp cheddar.

Is White American Cheese The Same As White Cheddar?

>White American cheese and white cheddar cheese are not the same, though they share some characteristics. They’re both dairy products and can be used interchangeably in many recipes, but there are significant differences in their composition, flavor, and texture.

  • White American Cheese: This is a type of processed cheese. It’s made from a blend of cheeses, ingredients like milk, milk fats and solids, and emulsifiers, giving it a smooth, creamy texture and great melting properties. It’s usually mild in flavor. The ‘white’ in its name refers to the fact that it hasn’t been colored – some American cheese is dyed orange, but there is no difference in taste or texture between the two.
  • White Cheddar Cheese: Cheddar cheese is a natural cheese traditionally made from cow’s milk. It’s known for its robust, tangy flavor and firm texture. The term ‘white cheddar’ means that the cheese hasn’t been dyed to give it orange, a common practice in some regions. White cheddar retains the natural color of the cheese, which can range from white to pale yellow.


Is American or cheddar cheese better on a burger?

Is American or cheddar cheese better on a burger
American cheese or yellow cheddar for burger

American cheese is more popular in burgers due to its creamy melting properties.

Is there any difference between yellow and white cheddar?

No, the color difference is due to adding annatto, a natural colorant.

Can you use American and cheddar cheese together?

Yes, they can create a balanced, creamy, and tangy flavor.

Is American cheese good for grilled cheese sandwiches?

Is American cheese good for grilled cheese sandwiches
Best Cheeses for Grilled Cheese Sandwich

Yes, its smooth melting properties make it perfect for grilled cheese sandwiches.

Is the Cheddar cheese in the UK different from cheddar cheese in the USA?

Yes, UK cheddar often has a stronger, more mature flavor due to different production methods.

Is Kraft American cheese real cheddar?

No, Kraft American cheese is a processed cheese product.

Why is cheddar cheese so delicious?

Its robust and tangy flavor, combined with its firm yet crumbly texture, makes it a favorite.

What is the white stuff on cheddar cheese slices?

It’s usually calcium lactate or tyrosine crystals, a sign of a well-aged cheese.

Which cheddar is for pizza?

Mild or medium cheddar is often used on pizza for its balanced flavor and good melting properties.

Can You Substitute American Cheese with Sharp Cheddar Cheese?

Yes, depending on the recipe. However, bear in mind that the flavor and texture will vary.


While American cheese and sharp cheddar cheese slices have unique qualities, they can elevate your dishes. Whether the creamy melt of American cheese on your burger or the rich tang of sharp cheddar on your cheeseboard, both kinds of cheese have a place in the culinary world. It’s all about personal preference and the flavor you seek for your dishes.

Key Notes:

  • American cheese is known for its smooth, creamy texture and mild flavor.
  • Sharp cheddar has a robust, tangy flavor and crumbly texture.
  • American cheese is widely used in comfort foods, while sharp cheddar is more versatile.
  • Cheddar cheese is generally higher in nutritional content compared to American cheese.
  • Making cheese at home is possible with the right ingredients and instructions.
  • Cheese substitution depends on the recipe and desired flavor and texture.
  • Both American cheese and cheddar cheese can enhance the flavor of your dishes.

American Cheese Slices vs Sharp Cheddar Cheese Slices

Characteristics American Cheese Slices Sharp Cheddar Cheese Slices
Origin Early 20th century, USA 12th-century, English village of Cheddar
Color Bright yellow or orange Naturally white to pale yellow
Texture Smooth and creamy Firm and slightly crumbly
Flavor Mild, slightly salty Robust, tangy, slightly nutty
Production Processed cheese with ingredients like milk, cream, and emulsifiers Made through the traditional “cheddaring” process
Uses Comfort foods, e.g., burgers, sandwiches Gourmet dishes, cheese platters, soups, sauces
Substitutes Monterey Jack, Colby cheese Swiss cheese, Gouda
Melting Property A smooth, creamy melt Stringy, gooey melt
Price Varies by brand, generally cheaper Varies by brand, generally more expensive due to traditional manufacturing

This table summarizes the key differences between American cheese slices and sharp cheddar cheese slices.